Call Your Own Store: The Hardest Sale You’ll Ever Experience

Calling your own dealership as a customer is one of the fastest ways for owners to see how easy or difficult it is to do business with their store. How phones are answered, how calls are handled, and whether anyone takes ownership or offers a next step directly impacts whether customers stay engaged or hang up and move on. Strong dealerships treat every call as a revenue opportunity and intentionally train and manage the phone experience because it often determines whether the sale ever begins.

Most dealership owners spend a lot of time reviewing financials, walking the showroom, and holding managers accountable. But there’s one diagnostic tool that costs nothing, takes 10 minutes, and delivers brutal honesty almost immediately:

Call your own store.

Not as the owner.
Not as “Hey, this is Brian.”
But as a customer.

Because the fastest way to understand how hard it is to do business with your company… is to try.

The First Impression Test

When you dial your store, ask yourself:

  • How many rings before someone answers?
  • Did a human answer, or did I hit a voicemail maze?
  • Was the greeting confident and welcoming—or rushed and indifferent?

Customers don’t start their buying journey in your showroom.
They start it right here, on the phone.

If the first 15 seconds feel inconvenient, confusing, or cold, most customers won’t push through. They’ll just hang up and call the next dealership.

The “Can You Help Me?” Moment

Now ask a simple question:

“I’m looking for a part / need service / want pricing information.”

Pay attention to what happens next.

  • Did the person take ownership or transfer you immediately?
  • Did they ask clarifying questions?
  • Did they sound interested in solving your problem—or ending the call?

Customers don’t call dealerships because it’s fun. They call because they need help. If your team sounds annoyed by that fact, the customer feels it instantly.

The Transfer Trap

Few things expose internal dysfunction faster than phone transfers.

  • Were you transferred correctly?
  • Did you get dumped into voicemail?
  • Did anyone come back to the line and explain what was happening?

Every transfer is a trust test.
Every dropped call is a lost opportunity.

If it’s frustrating for you as the owner, imagine how it feels for a first-time customer who doesn’t care about your internal staffing challenges.

The Close That Never Happens

Before hanging up, ask yourself one final question:

Did anyone try to earn my business?

  • Was an appointment offered?
  • Was my name captured?
  • Did anyone suggest a next step?

Many dealerships answer phones like information desks, not sales and service gateways. The call ends… and so does the opportunity.

Why Owners Avoid This Test

Let’s be honest—most owners don’t shop their own stores because they’re afraid of what they’ll hear.

But avoiding the truth doesn’t protect your brand.
It slowly erodes it.

Your phone process is either:

  • Making it easy to do business with you
    or
  • Quietly pushing customers away every single day

There is no middle ground.

The Fix Starts With Awareness

Shopping your own store isn’t about catching people doing things wrong.
It’s about understanding the customer experience you’re actually delivering—not the one you think you are.

The strongest dealerships:

  • Train phone skills intentionally
  • Hold managers accountable for call handling
  • Treat every call like revenue is on the line—because it is

Because the hardest sale you’ll ever make…
might be convincing a customer to stay on the line.